Maybe it could have still happened later, no one knows, but at that point it was really possible to preserve a united India. Nehru along with his aide V. Nehru had hoped to elevate Maulana Azad as the pre-eminent leader of Indian Muslims, but in this, he was undermined by Gandhi, who continued to treat Jinnah as the voice of Indian Muslims.
The inherent assumption is that demanding Pakistan was the wrong thing to do. Nehru and partition was a different kind of man. History ought to be examined, and re-examined, threadbare, before nations have the capacity to move on, is Hajari's contention.
Childhood[ edit ] Nehru described his childhood as a "sheltered and uneventful one". Untilhe described himself as Indian first and then Muslim. September Learn how and when to remove this template message Nehru worked closely with Subhas Chandra Bose in developing good relations with governments of free countries all over the world.
Or can he be? He is greatly admired and is father of the nation in Pakistan. He was a senior leader of the BJP and has been associated with it for long. Nehru angrily declared that "all the old problems Mr Jaswant Singh has thrown responsibility for partition on Jawaharlal Nehru.
Besant nevertheless Nehru and partition a league for advocating Home Rule in ; and Tilak, on his release from a prison term, had in April formed his own league.
He kept no diaries. Those perplexing riddles seeded the idea of doing a book on Partition. He is greatly admired and is father of the nation in Pakistan. After the protest gathered steam, they realised the power of salt as a symbol. However, Sardar Patel died inleaving Nehru as the sole remaining iconic national leader, and soon the situation became such that Nehru was able to implement many of his basic policies without hindrance.
Jinnah demanded that the exact words be said; Gandhi refused and the talks broke down. It is not only in India that Jinnah is subject to various interpretations, some hate him for dividing India while others absolve him of total responsibility for partition.
And RSS leaders hate him, though they may not take such a position publicly for obvious reasons. His subsequent sojourns in prison enabled him to study Marxism in more depth. Up until the spring ofa political compromise that would have preserved a united India, was still possible.
Before this crucial announcement, Nehru urged Jinnah and the Muslim League to join the protest but the latter declined. If one goes by Jinnah's speech in the Pakistan Constituent Assembly it is doubtful if he wanted even a Muslim state, let alone an Islamic state.
Anyone who was anti-national was described as communal. He had had it for years. Please help improve this section by adding citations to reliable sources. The motives for describing Jinnah as secular by two top BJP leaders may be different but there is an element of truth in what they say.
If one studies the complex developments carefully which took place in mid-fifties it is difficult to fix total responsibility on any one person or party. Jawaharlal was the eldest of three children, two of whom were girls.
The quality in Gandhi that impressed the two Nehrus was his insistence on action. He firmly placed India on the side of democracy and freedom during a time when the world was under the threat of fascism.
Of course these movements exercised tremendous pressure on the British Government and shook the government machinery. We believe also that if any government deprives a people of these rights and oppresses them the people have a further right to alter it or abolish it.
Some say Jawaharlal and I were estranged. Nehru was more fortunate in his efforts to solve the problem of the Portuguese colony of Goathe last remaining foreign-controlled entity in India. It is not only in India that Jinnah is subject to various interpretations, some hate him for dividing India while others absolve him of total responsibility for partition.
And as the larger, more powerful party it was their responsibility to accommodate it.Dec 21, · Please read something first before asking such a question. It was Sardar Patel who first agreed to the idea of partition with Jinnah, while Nehru and Gandhi were in jail.
Once both Nehru and Gandhi came to know of the deal, they strongly opposed i. In his autobiography, India Wins Freedom, Maulana Abul Kalam Azad presents a personal account of the Partition of India. There is a tinge of bitterness in Maulana’s account, which is not surprising because the partition of India was a traumatic experience for him.
Maulana began his journalistic and political career before World War I as a pan-Islamist, but switched to secular nationalism. News > Long Reads India at Horror of Partition sealed Nehru’s drive for a secular democracy after Independence.
Anil Dharker's parents loved the multicultural and multi-religious city of. Lord Mountbatten got Nehru, through his wife Advina to endorse the partition plan.
Thus it would be seen that apart from Jinnah the British and Nehru were also responsible for partition of the. Blaming Jawaharlal Nehru for the Partition of India in has lately become fashionable in the country’s political discourse. It is the view of a number of academics and experts that Nehru was.
This week, India and Pakistan both celebrate 70 years of independence.Download