For improvement proposals, the baseline is usually the improvement suggested by the team or an improvement that has strong management support.
How do alternative product design proposals compare to the current or preferred design? Is typically used in teams can just as Pugh matrix be used by individuals.
Select one potential improvement or product design as the baseline Pugh matrix all other proposals are compared to the baseline. Rates all proposals directly on how well they match the selection criteria Can provide a more realistic rating of the proposals because each proposal is rated directly on how well it matches the selection criteria, which creates much higher scores for better proposals.
Decision Matrix Decision Matrix Also called: We assess each of the alternatives B, C and D in the same way, filling in all the blanks.
Although the possible criteria could be many, the Pugh Matrix suggests using at least 3 viz. Selecting the appropriate datum is important because every solution will be evaluated against the datum. The third criteria is somewhere in between, so it's a three. And the last criteria is probably the most important so that it gets a five.
The Pugh Matrix is one of the most widely used methods of finding out the best solution once a number of alternate solutions have been generated. Also, the Pugh matrix is useful because it does not require a great amount of quantitative data on design concepts, which generally is not available at this point in the process anyway.
This will create a matrix with the criteria on the vertical axis and the solutions on the horizontal axis. A weighted decision matrix operates in the same way as the basic decision matrix but introduces the concept of weighting the criteria in order of importance.
So all the numbers to the right of it are multiplied by two. How-To Develop a list of the selection criteria. Typically, a Pugh matrix is used to evaluate various alternatives against a baseline. Data No data requirements exist because you only use this tool to collect and organize data.
The criteria is listed in a vertical list towards the extreme left of the paper or spreadsheet being used. Based on team input, score how well the baseline proposal matches each of the selection criteria. Usually, whichever group has fewer items occupies the vertical edge.
However, it has a record of coming up with the same solutions as mathematically intensive solutions would albeit with much less effort. The selection is made based on the consolidated scores.
Do this by distributing 10 points among the criteria. Within control of the team Financial payback Resources required for example; money and people Customer pain caused by the problem Urgency of problem Team interest or buy-in U Effect on other systems.
Weighting We can also give each criterion a weighting. Select the Datum The next step in the process is to select the Datum.It is also called a variety of names including Pugh method, Pugh analysis, decision matrix method, decision matrix, decision grid, selection grid, selection matrix, problem matrix, problem selection matrix, problem selection grid, solution matrix, criteria rating form, criteria-based matrix, opportunity analysis.
The Pugh matrix can also be used to rate proposed improvements vs a baseline improvement, which might be the improvement suggested by the team or by management, using organizational goals or customer needs as the criteria for comparison.
Another Pugh Matrix Template for Microsoft Excel. I felt the need to add a second Pugh Matrix Template as an example. This file comes with a blank template as well as a completed matrix for a home burglar system concept selection.
The pugh matrix can be used in a wide range of applications such as: deciding which investment to take, deciding which vendor to select, and deciding which improvement project to initiate.
The pugh matrix is a form of prioritization matrix in which the alternative proposals are compared against a standard. A Pugh Matrix Template in MS Excel format.
Use this template to determine the best solution from a set of solutions. You define a new process or a solution to a problem, then with this Pugh matrix template you can compare them to numerous factors or CTQ's defined by you and your project team.
Definition of Pugh Matrix: The Pugh matrix helps determine which items or potential solutions are more important or ‘better’ than others. It is employed after capturing voice of the customer (VOC).
It is a scoring matrix used for concept selection in which options are assigned scores relative to criteria.Download